Cyberflashing, fake news and the new crimes in the Online Safety Act

The UK’s first cyberflashing conviction, two weeks after it became a criminal offence, has renewed scrutiny of the scope of the Online Safety Act.

Nicholas Hawkes, a registered child sex offender from Basildon, Essex, sent “unsolicited photos of his genitals” to a woman and a girl aged 15 on 9 February, said The Times. The 39-year-old admitted two counts of sending a photo of genitals to cause alarm, distress or humiliation (punishable by up to two years in jail), and was convicted on Monday at Southend magistrates’ court. He will be sentenced at Basildon crown court in March. 

Cyberflashing became illegal in the UK on 31 January (it had been a crime in Scotland since 2010), along with a raft of other offences, when the controversial bill gained royal assent. 

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week’s Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

The conviction “shows the new law is working”, said CPS East of England. But the legislation faces vigorous opposition from free-speech campaigners and tech companies, who described it last year as “an unprecedented threat to the privacy, safety and security of every UK citizen” that could embolden “hostile governments” to draft “copy-cat laws”. 

What does the Online Safety Act cover?

The legislation, conceived in 2017, spent years mired in government turmoil with multiple ministers and amendments until it was given the all-clear last year. 

Much of the protections are designed to hold tech companies to account for content posted on social media, with bosses facing two years in jail if they consistently fail to protect children. 

Independent media regulator Ofcom has the power to fine platforms up to £18 million – or 10% of their annual revenue, whichever is higher – if they do not remove illegal content, including sexual abuse, terrorism or death threats. 

The amended act also includes several offences that “apply directly to the individuals sending threatening or menacing messages”, said the government’s press release

As well as cyberflashing, the act criminalises death threats, content that encourages self-harm, “revenge porn” (sharing intimate images without consent), and fake news that aims to cause “non-trivial physical or psychological harm”. 

The UK is the first country in the world to criminalise “epilepsy trolling”, or sending flashing images with the intention of provoking seizures. 

What are the issues?

At its genesis, the act was necessary to “address online material that was blamed for persuading teenagers to take their own lives”, said The Spectator, but it has now morphed into “a catch-all piece of legislation to suppress any material which someone, somewhere, may regard as ‘legal but harmful'”. 

Free-speech campaigners are also “broadly unhappy” with the act, said The New Statesman

Human rights organisation Article 19 called it “extremely complex and incoherent”, saying it would “undermine freedom of expression and information, [and] the right to privacy”. It also offers “no credible plan” to tackle disinformation and misinformation online, said fact-checking organisation Full Fact.

Others believe it does not go far enough to protect children. The mother of murdered teenager Brianna Ghey rejected Rishi Sunak’s “insistence” that the bill was adequate, said the BBC. Esther Ghey is campaigning for under-16s to be blocked from social media on smartphones and she told The Guardian that technology companies had a “moral responsibility” to restrict access to harmful content. 

To continue reading this article…

Create a free account

Continue reading this article and get limited website access each month.

Subscribe to The Week

Get unlimited website access, exclusive newsletters plus much more.

Subscribe & Save

Cancel or pause at any time.

Already a subscriber to The Week?